The Battle of the Bakgatla-Ba-Kgafela Community: Access to and Control of Communal Land

Juanita Magrietha Pienaar

Abstract


Like numerous other traditional communities in South Africa, the Bakgatla-Ba-Kgafela community lost portions of their ancestral land in the pre-constitutional era. Under an all-encompassing land reform programme, which also provides for the restitution of land in particular circumstances, a land claim was lodged. Having been successful with the land claim as all of the requirements set out in the Restitution of Land Rights Act 22 of 1994 were met, the first battle of the community in reclaiming their land had been won. The initial victory was short-lived as a second battle ensued, dealing with the governance of and form of control over the newly restored land. While the community wanted a communal property association, provided for in the Communal Property Associations Act 28 of 1996, the traditional leader preferred a trust. In this regard the various options of forms and constructs of collective ownership came into play. The second battle resulted in the Constitutional Court's deciding in favour of a communal property association in the light of the overall scheme of the Communal Property Associations Act, its objectives, the particular role of the Director-General of the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform, and all that had transpired in this particular case. This contribution deals with both of these battles, first setting out the struggle to reclaim the lost land, and then discussing the conflict over ownership and governance issues brought to finality in Bakgatla-Ba-Kgafela Communal Property Association v Bakgatla-Ba-Kgafela Tribal Authority 2015 6 SA 32 (CC). In this regard the judgment is analysed and thereafter reflected on with respect to recent developments linked specifically to communal property association legislation and then to other developments impacting on communal land and traditional communities in general. With regard to the former, recent draft amendments to the Communal Property Associations Act are highlighted, whereas policy developments and draft legislative measures are discussed with regard to the latter. While it is possible that some of the recent suggested amendments embodied in the Amendment Bill would have streamlined the process had these amendments been in operation when the Bakgatla-Ba-Kgafela community fought the second battle, various problems remain. In this context markedly different - conflicting - approaches emerged from the Constitutional Court judgment and official policy measures. Whereas the Court confirmed more democratic forms of ownership and governance in general, but specifically with respect to traditional communities, official policy documents coupled with draft legislative measures relating to traditional courts entrench traditional leadership constructs. In this regard more democratic forms of governance and ownership are seemingly reserved for areas outside traditional communal areas, most notably outside the former homelands. While the judgment handed down in the Constitutional Court may have brought closure to the Bakgatla-Ba-Kgafela community regarding the formation of a communal property association, the struggle of other traditional communities opting for communal property associations may just be beginning.


Keywords


Restitution of land Traditional communities Communal property association Communal property Communal land ownership Traditional leadership Bantustan Bakgatla-Ba-Kgafela community

Full Text:

PDF XML

References


BIBLIOGRAPHY

Literature

Adams, Cousins and Manana “Land tenure and economic development in rural South Africa: constraints and opportunities” Working Paper 125 PLAAS

Adams M, Cousins B and Manana S “Land tenure and economic development in rural South Africa: constraints and opportunities” Working Paper 125 (December 1999) PLAAS 7

Badenhorst, Pienaar and Mostert Silberberg & Schoeman’s Law of Property Badenhorst PJ, Pienaar JM & Mostert H Silberberg & Schoeman’s Law of Property 5th ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2006)

Beinart Twentieth century South Africa

Beinart W Twentieth century South Africa (Oxford University Press Oxford 2001)

Bennett “African land – A history of dispossession”

Bennett TW “African land – A history of dispossession” in R Zimmermann and D Visser (eds) Southern Cross: Civil Law and Common Law in South Africa (Juta Cape Town1996) 65-95

Boone 2007 African Affairs

Boone C “Property and constitutional order: land tenure reform and the future of the African state” 2007 African Affairs 557-586

Breutz A history of the Batswana and the origins of Bophuthatswana

Breutz PL A history of the Batswana and the origins of Bophuthatswana (Ramsgate Breutz RSA 1989)

Carey-Miller and Pope Land title in South Africa

Carey-Miller D and Pope A Land title in South Africa (Juta & Co. Kenwyn 2000)

Claassens “Contested power and apartheid tribal boundaries: the implications of ‘living customary law’ for indigenous accountability mechanisms”

Claassens A “Contested power and apartheid tribal boundaries: the implications if ‘living customary law’ for indigenous accountability mechanisms” in H Mostert and T Bennett (eds) Pluralism and Development: Studies in Access to Property in Africa (Juta Claremont 2012) 174-209

Cousins and Walker Land Divided Land Restored

Cousins B and Walker C (eds) Land Divided Land Restored: Land Reform in South Africa for the 21st Century (Jacana Media Johannesburg 2015)

Cousins “Characterising ‘communal tenure’: nested systems and flexible boundaries”

Cousins B “Characterising ‘communal tenure’: nested systems and flexible boundaries” in A Claassens and B Cousins (eds) Land, power and custom (UCT Press Cape Town 2008) 109-137

Cousins et al Perspectives on land tenure security in rural and urban areas

Cousins B, Hornby D, Kingwell R, Royston L and Trench T Land, Memory, Reconstruction and Justice: Perspectives on land tenure security in rural and urban areas (Ohio University Press Athens 2005)

Devenish “The development of administrative and political control over rural blacks”

Devenish GE “The development of administrative and political control over rural blacks” in AJ Rycroft, LJ Boulle, MK Robertson and PR Spiller (eds) Race and the law in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 1987) 29-41

Dubow Apartheid 1948-1994

Dubow S Apartheid 1948-1994 (Oxford University Press United Kingdom 2014)

Du Plessis, Pienaar and Olivier 2009 2 SAPL/PR

Du Plessis W, Pienaar JM and Olivier NJJ “Land Matters and rural development” 2009 2 SAPL/PR 608-610

Evans 2012 SA Historical Journal

Evans L “South Africa’s Bantustans and the dynamics of ‘decolonization’: Reflections on writing histories of the homelands” 2012 SA Historical Journal 117-137

Haines and Cross “An historical overview of land policy and tenure in South Africa’s black areas”

Haines R and Cross C “An historical overview of land policy and tenure in South Africa’s black areas” in C Cross and R Haines (eds) Towards freehold: Options for Land and Development in South Africa’s Black Rural Areas (Juta Cape Town1988) 73-92

Hall “Reconciling the past, present and the future”

Hall R “Reconciling the past, present and the future” in Walker C, Bohlin A, Hall T and Kepe T (eds) Land, Memory, Reconstruction and Justice: Perspectives on Land Claims in South Africa (Ohio University Press Athens 2010) 17-40

Keegan Colonial South Africa and the origins of the racial order

Keegan T Colonial South Africa and the origins of the racial order (Leicester University Press London 1996)

Magala History of the Bakgatla baga Kgafela

Magala J History of the Bakgatla baga Kgafela (Crink Pretoria 2009)

Manson and Mbenga Land, Chiefs, Mining

Manson A and Mbenga B Land, Chiefs, Mining: South Africa’s North West Province Since 1840 (Witwatersand University Press Johannesburg 2014)

McCarthy “African land tenure as a popular issue and power relations in South African urban and peri-urban areas”

McCarthy JJ “African land tenure as a popular issue and power relations in South African urban and peri-urban areas” in C Cross and R Haines (eds) Towards freehold: Options for Land and Development in South Africa’s Black Rural Areas (Juta Cape Town 1988) 122-127

Morton When rustling became an art

Morton F When rustling became an art: Pilane’s Kgatla and the Transvaal frontier, 1820-1902 (David Philip Publishers Cape Town 2009)

Mostert and Pope Principles of law of property

Mostert H and Pope A (eds) Principles of law of property (Oxford University Southern Press 2010)

Mostert and De Waal (eds) Essays in honour of CG van der Merwe

Mostert H and MJ de Waal (eds) Essays in honour of CG van der Merwe (LexisNexis Durban 2011) 309-330

Okoth-Ogendo “The nature of land rights under indigenous law in Africa”

Okoth-Ogendo HWO “The nature of land rights under indigenous law in Africa” in A Claassens and B Cousins (eds) Land, power and custom (UCT Press Cape Town 2008) 95-109.

Pienaar “Land reform and restitution in South Africa: An embodiment of justice?”

Pienaar JM “Land reform and restitution in South Africa: An embodiment of justice?” in De Ville J (ed) Memory and Meaning: Lourens du Plessis and the Haunting of Justice (Lexisnexis Durban 2015) 141-160

Pienaar “’As a result of racially discriminatory laws and practices’ for purposes of the Restitution of Land Rights Act 22 of 1994: case law analysis”

Pienaar JM ‘’As a result of racially discriminatory laws and practices’ for purposes of the Restitution of Land Rights Act 22 of 1994: case law analysis” in M Habdas and A Wudarski (eds) Festschrift fur Stanislawa Kalus (Frankfurt am Main Peter Lang 2010) 385-408

Pienaar Land Reform

Pienaar JM Land Reform (Juta Cape Town 2014)

Pienaar 2008 Stell LR

Pienaar GJ “The inclusivity of communal land tenure: a redefinition of ownership in Canada and South Africa” 2008 Stellenbosch Law Review 259-277

Pienaar “’Unlawful occupier’ in perspective: history, legislation and case law”

Pienaar JM “’Unlawful occupier’ in perspective: history, legislation and case law” in H Platzky and C Walker C The surplus people: Forced removals in South Africa (Raven Press Johannesburg 1985) 309-330

Rautenbach and Bekker (eds) Introduction to Legal Pluralism

Rautenbach C and Bekker JC (eds) Introduction to Legal Pluralism 4th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2014)

Robertson “Black land tenure: disabilities and some rights”

Robertson MK “Black land tenure: disabilities and some rights” in AJ Rycroft, LJ Boulle, MK Robertson and PR Spiller (eds) Race and the law in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 1987) 119-139

Schoombee 1985 Acta Juridica

Schoombee H “Group areas legislation – The political control of ownership and of occupation of land” 1985 Acta Juridica 77-107

Sparks The mind of South Africa

Sparks A The mind of South Africa (Random House Cape Town 2011)

Thompson A History of South Africa

Thompson L A History of South Africa 4th ed (Yale University Press New Haven 2014)

Van der Merwe, Pienaar and De Waal International Encyclopaedia of Laws: Property and Trust Law – South Africa

Van der Merwe CG, Pienaar JM and De Waal MJ International Encyclopaedia of Laws: Property and Trust Law – South Africa ((Wolters Kluwer 2015) Part III – Trust and Fiduciary mechanisms

Van der Merwe and Pienaar “Land reform in South Africa”

Van der Merwe CG and Pienaar JM ‘Land reform in South Africa’ in P Jackson and DC Wilde (eds) The Reform of Property Law (Ashgate Aldershot 1997) 334-380

Van der Merwe 1989 TSAR 663-692

Van der Merwe D “Land tenure in South Africa: a brief history and some reform proposals” 1989 TSAR 663-692

Walker Land marked

Walker C Land marked: Land Claims and Land Restitution in South Africa (Jacana Johannesburg 2008)

Weeks “Securing women’s property inheritance in the context of plurality: negotiations of law and authority in Mbuzini customary courts and beyond”

Weeks S “Securing women’s property inheritance in the context of plurality: negotiations of law and authority in Mbuzini customary courts and beyond” in H Mostert and TW Bennett Pluralism and Development (Juta Cape Town 2011) 140-173

Case law

Bakgatla-Ba-Kgafela Communal Property Association v Bakgatla-Ba-Kgafela Tribal Authority 2015 6 SA 32 (CC)

Department of Land Affairs, Popela Community v Goedgelegen Tropical Fruits (Pty) Ltd 2007 6 SA 199 (CC).

Florence v Government of the Republic of South Africa 2014 6 SA 456 (CC)

Land Access Movement of South Africa v Chairperson of the National Council of Provinces Case CCT 40/15, [2016] ZACC 22.

Ndebele-Ndzundza Community v Farm Kafferskraal 2003 5 SA 375 (SCA).

Tongoane v Minister of Agriculture and Land Affairs 2010 6 SA 214 (CC)

Legislation

Abolition of Racially Based Land Measures Act 108 of 1991

Black Administration Act 38 of 1927

Black Land Act 27 of 1913

Communal Land Rights Act 11 of 2004

Restitution of Land Rights Act 22 of 1994

South African Development Trust and Land Act 18 of 1936

Traditional Leadership and Governance Framework Act 41 of 2003

Government Publications

Gen Not 464 GG 39943 of 22 April 2016

GN R526 in GG 37791 of 1 July 2014

Proc R188 in GG 2486 of 11 July 1969

Gen Not 901 in GG 34850 of 13 December 2011

Department of Rural Development and Land Reform Communal Land Tenure Policy (September 2014)

Internet sources

Centre for Law and Society date unknown http://www.customcontested.co.za/constitutoinal-court-confirms-value-of-cpas-in-traitinal-communities.

Centre for Law and Society date unknown Constitutional Court affirms value of CPA in traditional communities http://www.customcontested.co.za/constitutoinal-court-confirms-value-of-cpas-in-traitinal-communities, accessed 24 April 2016.

Department of Rural Development and Land Reform 2015 http://pmg.org.za/committee-meeting/17873.

Department of Rural Development and Land Reform 2015 Communal Property Associations 2012/13 and 2013/14 Annual Reports: Department of Rural Development and Land Reform Briefing http://pmg.org.za/committee-meeting/17873, accessed 20 May 2016

Loate date unknown http://www.plaas.org.za.

Loate L date unknown Communal Land tenure policy: State land grabbing and the coercive use of land to create voting blocks? http://www.plaas.org.za, accessed 2 March 2016

Anon 2013 http://www.dla.gov.za/phocadownload/1913/DRDLR_2009Manifesto_Report.pdf

Anon 2013 The Land Manifesto http://www.dla.gov.za/phocadownload/1913/DRDLR_2009Manifesto_Report.pdf, accessed 31 August 2015




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2017/v20i0a1444

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2017 Juanita Magrietha Pienaar

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.