Vox Populi? Vox Humbug! – Rising Tension between the South African Executive and Judiciary Considered in Historical Context – Part Two

Stephen Peté



Part One of this article traced rising tensions between the South African executive and the judiciary on the question of the separation of powers. This situation was then contrasted and compared with a clash which took place in the 17th century between King James I of England and Chief Justice Edward Coke. In Part Two of this article attention is focused on two specific cases which arose out of the clash between James and Coke - Prohibitions Del Roy and The Case of Proclamations. The article then turns to a discussion of the lessons which can be drawn from these cases. The arguments which were raised in the cases are contrasted and compared with more contemporary arguments advanced in the context of the present conflict between the South African executive and the judiciary. The views of Ronald Dworkin comparing 'majoritarian' and 'constitutional' conceptions of democracy are examined in the context of this debate. Tentative conclusions are then drawn and warnings issued of the negative consequences for South Africa if the potential conflict between the executive and the judiciary is not properly resolved.


: constitutional democracy; separation of powers; majoritarian democracy; Golden Metwand; James I; Edward Coke; Jacob Zuma; executive; judiciary; Ronald Dworkin; rule of law

Full Text:




Ackroyd History of England

Ackroyd P Foundation: The History of England Volume 1 (Pan London 2012)

Churchill History of the English Speaking Peoples

Churchill WS A History of the English Speaking Peoples - 5 The Civil War 1603-49 (Cassell London 1965)

Dworkin Freedom's Law

Dworkin R Freedom's Law (Oxford University Press Oxford 1996)

Dworkin Justice for Hedgehogs

Dworkin R Justice for Hedgehogs (Belknap Press of Harvard University Press Cambridge, Mass 2011)

Hart Law, Liberty and Morality

Hart HLA Law, Liberty and Morality (Stanford University Press Stanford CA 1963)

Hindley Magna Carta

Hindley G Magna Carta (Running Press London 2008)

Klare 1998 SAJHR

Klare K "Legal Culture and Transformative Constitutionalism" 1998 SAJHR 146-188

Prosser and Sharp Short Constitutional History

Prosser CW and Sharp M A Short Constitutional History of England (Longmans, Green London 1938 & 1941)

Roux 2009 Stell L R

Roux T "Transformative Constitutionalism and the Best Interpretation of the South African Constitution: Distinction Without a Difference" 2009 Stell L R 258-285

Stoner Common Law

Stoner JR Common Law and Liberal Theory: Coke, Hobbes, and the Origins of American Constitutionalism (University Press of Kansas Lawrence, Kan 1992)

Register of legislation

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Register of cases

Prohibitions Del Roy 1607 77 ER 1342

The Case of Proclamations 1610 77 ER 1352

Thomas Bonham v College of Physicians 1610 77 ER 638 (CP)

Register of internet sources

Baron 1987 www.nytimes.com

Baron J 'Sherman Letters Show Civil War General Regarded Reporters as 'Spies'' New York Times 21 June 1987 www.nytimes.com/1987/06/21/us/sherman-letters-show-civil-war-general-regarded-reporters-as-spies.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm [date of use 17 Sep 2012]

Britannica Date Unknown www.britannica.com

Britannica Encyclopaedia Online Date Unknown Court of the Star Chamber www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/563475/Court-of-Star-Chamber [date of use 17 Sep 2012]

De Vos 2012 constitutionallyspeaking.co.za

De Vos P 2012 NEC should not Conflate the Party and the State constitutionallyspeaking.co.za/nec-should-not-conflate-the-party-and-the-state/ [date of use 15 Aug 2012]

Hartley 2011 www.bdlive.co.za

Hartley W 'Executive superior to courts, says Zuma' Business Day 2 November 2011 www.bdlive.co.za/articles/2011/11/02/executive-superior-to-courts-says-zuma [date of use 17 Sep 2012]

IEC 2009 www.elections.org.za

IEC 2009 National and Provincial Elections Results www.elections.org.za/content/Pages/LGE_NPE_Reports/Reports.aspx?lEEtypeID=1&id=1426&name=Elections [date of use 17 Sep 2012]

Sapa 2012 www.timeslive.co.za

Sapa ''You have less rights because you're a minority': Zuma' Times Live 13 September 2012 www.timeslive.co.za/politics/2012/09/13/you-have-less-rights-because-you-re-a-minority-zuma [date of use 17 Sep 2012]

Statistics SA 2009 www.statssa.gov.za

Statistics SA 2009 Population Statistics www.statssa.gov.za/publications/populationstats.asp [date of use 17 Sep 2012]

Ngalwa 2011 www.timeslive.co.za

Ngalwa S 'God is on the ANC's side, Zuma tells crowd' Times Live 5 February 2011 www.timeslive.co.za/sundaytimes/article895148.ece/God-is-on-the-ANCs-side-Zuma-tells-crowd [date of use 17 Sep 2012]

Wikiquotes Date Unknown en.wikipedia.org

Wikiquotes Date Unknown Vox Populi en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vox_populi [date of use 17 Sep 2012]

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2012/v15i5a2519


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2017 Stephen Peté

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.